Skip to main content

USS Indianapolis: Men of Courage: Average Guy Movie Review


In 1945 the Americans dropped the world's first atomic bomb on the Japanese city of Hiroshima. Components and uranium for the bomb were delivered to Tinian, the island airfield where the bombers were based by the USS Indianapolis. The Indianapolis - a Portland class heavy cruiser - usually travelled with an escort of destroyers in order to protect against enemy submarines. But due to the secret nature of the mission it was decided that this journey should be completed unescorted. The journey to Tinian was completed in record time, after making their delivery they headed for Leyte. At 00:14 hours on 30th July Indianapolis was struck by two torpedoes from a Japanese submarine, she sank in twelve minutes. Approximately three hundred men went down with the ship, the rest faced dehydration, starvation, exposure and shark attacks as they awaited rescue.

USS Indianapolis
If you've seen Jaws this story may sound familiar, Quint (Robert Shaw) describes the incident in detail having been a (fictional) member of the crew. Considered the worst disaster in US Naval history, the sinking resulted in what's believed to be the largest number of shark attacks on humans. As a fan of history I think this a story that definitely needs telling. How is it such a little known story considering it's a major part of the history of the atomic bomb and the end of the war?


I wish I could say that USS Indianapolis: Men of Courage does justice to the crew and their story, unfortunately it doesn't. Nicolas Cage is very good as Captain McVay, he does a great job portraying a man struggling with the loss of so many of his crew and the guilt that came with it. Tom Sizemore is also very good as Chief Petty Officer McWhorter. All of the other performances range from good to awful. Obviously the focus of the story is on their time in the water and is done very well for the most part. The delivery of the bomb components felt rushed as did the events after the rescue. A sub-plot involving two sailors and their love for the same woman felt tacked on, an unnecessary attempt to humanise the crew.


The production values aren't great either, most of the CGI is of very low quality. The battleship USS Alabama was used as a stand in for the Indianapolis, this is the same ship used in Steven Seagal's Under Siege. During the sinking you see some brilliant shots of the torpedo strikes and the ship buckling, the decks are burning and torn apart. Yet in the next shot you see men running across intact decks. While in the water, the men suffered frequent and unpredictable shark attacks, not only do the computer generated sharks look terrible but they're also the wrong sharks. In the movie they're depicted as Great Whites whereas in reality the crew were mostly attacked by Oceanic White Tip and Tiger sharks.


USS Indianapolis: Men of Courage is definitely a movie that people should see. I would encourage anyone to watch it, simply to appreciate the level of sacrifice an entire generation made for our freedom. It's a return to form for Nicolas Cage, but weak performances from some of the supporting cast and poor production values let it down.

6/10


What did you think of USS Indianapolis: Men of Courage? Let us know by leaving a comment below or find us on Facebook and Twitter.

Comments

  1. I agree with this review. I had been saying for a long time that this story needed to be told, there is another much older film I saw with my Father years ago. But this effort is just an embarrassment . The cgi looks as though it cost a fiver, especially in the opening scene. It doesn't even attempt to get its facts right , as it uses the wrong sharks, they should have been tiger sharks . Lazy and shoddy film making and cringeworthy acting which is a shame ,as it's a story that people should know.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for leaving a comment, your support is always appreciated. I expected a lot more from Hollywood with this one! On the plus side, their story has been told and it's believed the movie sticks closely to historical events. It just doesn't do their story justice.

      Delete

Post a comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Snyder Cut | Wouldn't Be The First Time a Director Got a Second Chance

It seems that a fairly common occurrence amongst movies tied to Warner Bros. is the magical disappearing/reappearing director. Does that mean there's hope for the Snyder Cut? I certainly hope so!


Ever since Justice League hit cinemas in 2017 - possibly even before - fans have been calling for Zack Snyder's original vision to be released. Snyder famously faced issues regarding the darker tone and longer run times his movies were taking, especially after the negative response to 'Batman v Superman'. This of course led to rewrites of the superhero team-up movie, and certain plotlines established or teased in 'BvS' - including the epic Knightmare scene - being dropped. The director then left the production after the tragic death of his daughter. Joss Whedon was brought in by the studio to finish the movie, this included the completion of post production and some major reshoots, further altering the movie. All of which resulted in a movie that is drastically differen…

Dune | Moustache Trailer Reaction

Like one of the massive space ships that feature within it, the trailer for Denis Villeneuve's take on 'Dune' has landed... and it's magnificent. If you've not seen it, or you simply want to watch it again, you can check it out below:

Trying to tame Frank Herbert's legendary sci-fi novel, it seems, is a challenge like no other. But if anyone is up to the task, it's a fair bet that it's Denis Villeneuve. The French-Canadian director is no stranger to reviving beloved sci-fi properties; Blade Runner 2049 is a worthy sequel to the original Blade Runner, and an outstanding movie in its own right - the best of 2017 in my opinion. Add to that his previous projects (Sicario, Arrival, Prisoners), and you've got a director with a talent for combining complex narratives, fascinating characters and stunning visuals, in a way that's both gripping and intelligible.


From the moment the trailer begins you can feel the epic scale of what has been created here. Gr…

Moustache Lockdown Streaming Survival Guide Part 6 | Home Before Dark

We're back on Apple TV+ this week, checking out one of Apple's new TV shows: Home Before Dark.



As always you can check out the previous post in our Moustache Lockdown Streaming Survival Guide by clicking here.





Ever since her Dad took her into the newsroom where he works, nine year old Hilde Lisko (Brooklynn Prince) has been fascinated with journalism. So fascinated in fact, that she started her own newspaper - The Magic Hour Chronicle. But when Matthew Lisko (Jim Sturgess) - Hilde's Father - loses his job, the family is forced to move to Matthew's home town of Erie Harbor, a place he hasn't been back to in many years. There, a chance encounter leads Hilde to look into a thirty year cold case, one that involved the murder of a teenage boy and tore the town apart. Could that be the reason why Hilde's Dad left and never came back?




I will admit that when my fiancé and I were checking out the new content available on Apple TV+ (we had just finished watching the availab…