Skip to main content

The Optimist | Average Guy Movie Review


For Sixty years Herbert Heller (Stephen Lang) hid from all that knew him the fact that he was a survivor of the Holocaust. But when a terminal diagnosis inspires him to finally share what happened to him and his family, he forms an unlikely bond with troubled teen, Abbey (Elsie Fisher). It is through this friendship, and the sharing of their stories, that the pair are able to begin healing.



It seems appropriate somehow, that I am sat writing this review on Remembrance Day 2026. At a time when the number of people who remember the second world war and the cruelty of the Nazis is rapidly decreasing, it is important to learn all that we can from them. That, in a way, is the spirit of The Optimist (which depending on where you live and on what format you're looking to view it, might be called The Optimist: The Bravest Act is Truth or Liberation). Herbert sadly passed away in 2021, but in a way this film continues to share his work. On its own, Herbert's story of survival is an incredible one. Living in Czechoslovakia under Nazi occupation, before being sent to the Terezin Ghetto, and eventually Auschwitz-Birkenau. He escaped from one of the infamous death marches, and emigrated to the US after the war. But the fact that he kept all of that from everyone for so long, and then when he eventually did share his experiences he found a way to use it to help others, makes him and his story extraordinary.



Stephen Lang delivers a beautiful performance as Herbert. As does Luke David Blumm, who plays a young Herbert living in Czechoslovakia under Nazi occupation. Together they give us a sense of the pain that the man carried with him for so many years, while also showing us the optimistic and caring person he became despite all that happened to him. Much of which is thanks to his father (Slavko Sobin) - who strived even in the worst times to keep his family's hopes alive - and we see through his interactions with Elsie Fisher's Abbey. She and Lang are magnificent together. Abbey may be a fictional character, but she is no doubt representative of many people that Herbert helped over the years, and Fisher has no trouble in making her feel very real. So much so, that despite all that they are dealing with, it is rather wonderful to watch their friendship grow, as they help each other to heal.



Cutting back and forth between 2004 - when Herbert began to open up about his past - and the 1930's & 40's, writer/director Finn Taylor essentially allows Herbert to tell us his story, while showing us how the patient and softly-spoken man used his experiences to help others open up about theirs. The scenes depicting his younger years, while horrifying, are also strikingly affecting in a very different way, and that is thanks to Herbert's seemingly unbreakable spirit. Through Lang's performance we see a weight essentially lifted as he begins to share with Abbey, but it's the way he simply talks and listens to her that is truly heart-warming. Abbey, on the other hand, understandably takes a little longer to open up, with Fisher bringing a genuine sense of discomfort and reluctance to the troubled teen. Which makes it all the more wonderful to watch Abbey not only find someone she can talk to, but develop the strength within herself to confront her own demons. That in itself is a fitting tribute to the man and all he did to help others. 



A beautiful film about a man who after sixty years of hiding his past, found a way to help both himself and others by opening up. The Optimist is a fitting tribute to Herbert Heller and a wonderful way to share his work, so that others may continue to benefit from it.

8/10


What did you think of The Optimist? Leave a comment below or find us on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and Threads. You can also email us at moviemoustache@gmail.com.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Mission: Impossible - The Final Reckoning | Average Guy Movie Review

Two months after acquiring both halves of the cruciform key, Ethan Hunt (Tom Cruise) is ready to put an end to the Entity, once and for all. However, in that time the rogue A.I. has increased its stranglehold on cyber space and the planet. Spreading lies and misinformation, the people of the world are divided more than ever, and governments are on high alert. All of which should make it rather difficult, maybe even impossible for Ethan and his team to find a sunken Russian submarine and, use whatever they find there to kill the artificial intelligence that's slowly taking control of the world's nuclear arsenals. It is entirely possible that Mission: Impossible - The Final Reckoning  could be the most anxiety inducing instalment of the franchise - the second half, anyway. Once again, Tom Cruise puts himself through the absolutely ludicrous in the name of entertainment... and a possible adrenaline addiction. Every scenario in which Ethan and the gang find themselves seems to be d...

Jason Bourne: Spoiler Review

I don't usually write spoiler filled reviews because I don't see the point. But considering my not so positive review of Jason Bourne, one of the most highly anticipated movies of Summer 2016, I thought it might be worth trying to explain why I reached the verdict I did. If you haven't seen this movie stop reading because there are spoilers ahead. Click here to see the spoiler free review. The movie begins with Bourne in Greece. He's laying low, making money by competing in underground fights and still struggling with his past. He lacks purpose which is making him miserable. Nicky Parsons on the other hand is busy hacking the CIA in order to expose their black ops programs. So far so good. But when Nicky finds something out about Jason's (or should I say David's) past, she heads to Greece to find him. Unfortunately her activities have drawn the attention of CIA Agent Heather Lee (Alicia Vikander), a cyber ops specialist who begins to track her. Using a ...

4DX – Is it worth it or just a gimmick?

This week I saw Ghostbusters in 4DX and it definitely made the movie more of a ride. In fact 4DX feels like it was designed to appeal to the roller coaster crowd but will you miss the experience when watching the same movies at home? When I saw Ghostbusters for the second time I decided to view it in 4DX because I wanted to know what the "environmental effects" did for the movie going experience. If you want to know what I thought of Ghostbusters check out my Average Guy Movie Review . In my honest opinion; right now 4DX is more of a gimmick than an experience. The movement, air bursts, smoke and spraying water were more of a distraction than anything else, all of which felt out of sink with the movie. The effects like the strobe lights went off a split second before whatever they were supposed to augment happened. For example; during a subway scene, the Ghostbusters find a ghost in the tunnel who had been executed using an electric chair. The ghost levitated and as...